The Changing Brain Studied Through Violence
I have recently read a paper that, I believe, has not received the attention it deserves, at least in the media. It is a study of the re-organization of the brain in response to violence. What it is that suddenly triggers a violent behaviour in some individuals is not known with any certainty, but it has long been suspected that exposure to violence leads to increased violence. We have, after all, been repeatedly told that watching violent movies results in individuals who are more readily capable of violence. But why and how?
A paper by Chris Kelly and his colleagues at Columbia Univeristy has far-reaching implications in this regard. They showed volunteer subjects clips of violent films and measured activity in different areas of the brain, using brain imaging techniques. Their results show, in brief, that repeated exposure to violence reduces the intensity of activity in a specific region of the brain known as the lateral orbito-frontal cortex progressively. The implication here is that the more violent movies are watched, the greater the reduction in orbito-frontal activity. This in itself may suggest an adaptation that makes individuals more immune to violence, adaptation being a very common occurrence in the brain. But the study goes further, to show that connections between brain areas must be in a dynamic state, and hence modifiable by experience - in this case the experience of violence - even in adult life. For the orbito-frontal cortex is connected with another brain area - the amygdala - which is known to be responsive to fearful and aggressive faces. This connection seems to be critical in the control of aggressive behaviour. The strength of connections between the two brain areas diminished progressively as violent movies were watched, and led to more aggressive tendencies. The study also strongly suggested that there developed a progressive diminished control over the initiation of violent aggressive behaviour. For there was a concomitant increase in activity within areas known to be critical in motor planning (for aggressive behaviour, among others). This suggests that the connections between the orbito-frontal cortex and yet other regions of the cortex are also in a dynamic state.
It is important to note that the study exposed subjects to violent films over relatively brief periods, each clip viewed lasting seconds rather than hours, as is common for violent movies. Hence, it does not take prolonged exposure to alter strength of connections in the brain, and in this instance, to loosen the inhibition that leads to violent aggressive behaviour.
There is a lesson in this for society, and that is why I am surprised that so little has been made of it by the media. We have discussed endlessly whether the extent of violence shown in Western movies is not damaging our already violent societies. And yet here is a study, which shows that even brief exposure can alter the balance of connections in the brain and tip them in a direction that is not socially advantageous. And there is, perhaps, a problem for legislators too. What if someone can come armed with evidence derived from brain scans to show that the crimes that he or she has committed is the result of altered brain states, induced by watching violent movies? It would be a manner of shifting responsibility. I do not know enough about law to discuss this point, but I should not be at all surprised if defense of this kind surfaces in future hearings of criminal violence cases.
But there is, above all, a great deal of interest in learning that such complex behaviour is held in check by a fine system of balance through the interactions between brain areas and that this balance is so vulnerable - even over very brief periods and even in adult life - to environmental influences. There is much in this work that is of interest for future studies in the neurobiology of aggressive behaviour and violence.
Since 1970 Zeki has been based at University College, being appointed the Professor of Neurobiology in 1981. Here he details his theories on the intimate connections between the brain, the mind and experience.
How Habits are Formed by Our Mind
Pattern recognition and association Our brain is internally programmed through association.
Since we were born our brain starts to recognize pattern of stimulus through our senses.
Pattern is defined as a repeated form of something.
When something is repeated frequent enough our brain recognize it as a pattern.Once a pattern is recognized, our ...
Public Relations for the Pope
The Catholic Pope is starting to make a lot of sense and it has angered some in the Islamic World who are upset. They are now calling for his death, not his resignation. Indeed in doing this it seems they are proving him right about his historical account of Islam. Unfortunately, this is now making a mockery of Islam or the radicals of Islam are ma...
Children, War, and Terrorism
As we all watch the horrific devastation in Israel, Gaza, and Lebanon on the news day after day, glued to the tube, we have to be thinking, Where does it end? When does it end? Will it ever end? Periodic military and diplomatic solutions in the Middle East since 1949 have attempted to provide a lasting peace in the region. And yet, here we are ...
Preventing Future Violence
The life of a chronically violent person is a matrix of complex interactive systems. Behavior can best be understood by examining the dynamics of the individuals social context, psychological characteristics, biology, and environment. Chronic violence does not just happen one day, it develops, usually in childhood and progresses through adulthood...
Borderline Schizophrenics and Paranoid People
In psychology classes in colleges across America, they discuss the issues of paranoia and schizophrenics. Such anomalies are fun to study and generally they are studied as brain disorders. But there are some very interesting facts about these folks, which often do not consider. First many borderline schizophrenics are off the chart on the side of i...
California Divorce and Child Custody: What is a Mediator?
A mediator in California can help parents involved in a contested child custody and visitation dispute resolve their disagreements in mediation without a litigated hearing. Mediation is a mandatory process in California that must take place before a contested issue regarding custody and visitation is heard in a litigated hearing as pointed out in ...
Social Psychology: The Psychological Explanations of Social Phenomena
The various aspects of social psychology could be examined within the wide concepts of intelligence, gender, advertising, consumer culture, stress and psychological issues that define society. Considering consumer behaviour, social psychology uses convincing theories to explain addictive consumption, the influence of advertising and the phenomenon ...